
Racine County Board moves to release the Kite investigation reports behind Cary Madrigal's discipline |
Racine County supervisors want a resolution waiving attorney-client privilege on two Kite investigation reports. The full board votes Dec. 8.
Updated Nov. 18, 2026, 7:30 p.m.: Adds the Wisconsin Department of Justice’s response and that Madrigal and the Sheriff’s Office did not answer questions about the media update by deadline. An earlier update Wednesday added a Sheriff’s Office media update that ties Capt. Cary Madrigal’s administrative leave to the Union Grove superintendent investigation.
RACINE COUNTY, Wis. — Racine County residents may soon get to read the outside investigation behind Capt. Cary Madrigal’s 2025 suspension, which became an issue in this year’s race for sheriff.
After meeting behind closed doors Tuesday night, the Racine County Board’s Committee of the Whole voted in open session to have the county’s lawyer draft a resolution that would waive attorney-client privilege and release two redacted reports from the law firm Crivello, Nichols & Hall, according to a media release County Board Chairman Tom Kramer issued Wednesday.
The reports came out of the firm’s review of the Racine County Sheriff’s Office after the arrest of former deputy Preston Kite. The county’s corporation counsel says they are commonly called the “Hall reports.” Racine County Eye has previously reported that attorney Samuel C. Hall Jr. conducted the investigation.
The two reports up for release were directed to the county’s human resources director and are dated Dec. 2, 2024, and Feb. 4, 2025, according to the release.
“Those two (2) subject reports served as the foundation for discipline on Captain Cary Madrigal stemming from her response to allegations that another deputy received an inappropriate photo from Kite,” the release says.
Nothing has been released yet. The release does not say how supervisors voted. The resolution goes to the Committee of the Whole on Dec. 8, and the full County Board will consider adopting it at its meeting the same day, according to the release.
“The Racine County Board takes seriously the importance of preserving investigation integrity, employee privacy, and fundamental legal obligations (including attorney-client privilege),” Kramer said in the release. “It also embraces the County’s longstanding commitment to transparency and accountability and is entrusted to effectively honor and balance those critical interests.”
Why this matters
Since May, the public has seen only one side of these reports: the sheriff’s summary of them.
That summary became public after Madrigal went to court over the county’s plan to release her discipline file. Racine County Circuit Judge Eugene Gasiorkiewicz ruled the records should be released, and Madrigal posted them to her campaign website in May. The court dismissed her complaint May 22 in case 2026CV000280, court records show. Madrigal has told Racine County Eye her goal was to make sure the redactions were proper, not to seal the file.
When Racine County Eye reviewed Madrigal’s discipline file in August, her 10-day unpaid suspension came through a disciplinary complaint that Sheriff Christopher Schmaling filed Feb. 19, 2025, and wrote as a summary of the outside investigator’s findings. The reports themselves were never released. Madrigal told Racine County Eye then that she had not seen them either.
“I was only given the Sheriff’s summary that I released,” she said.
That summary also changed the investigator’s timeline. Schmaling wrote that the investigator “incorrectly concluded” the order of two 2023 conversations and moved one of them months earlier, which is what produced the finding that Madrigal failed to act in “the summer and fall of 2023.” Racine County Eye could not resolve that dispute because the reports had not been released.
One of the two reports the board would release is the follow-up dated Feb. 4, 2025, which the county’s corporation counsel describes as “a brief follow-up regarding a discrepancy in the timeline of events.” Schmaling filed the disciplinary complaint 15 days later.
What the county says the investigation found
Racine County Corporation Counsel Michael J. Lanzdorf laid out the investigation in a Nov. 13 memo to the County Board, with copies to Schmaling, Sheriff-elect Donald Vandervest and County Executive Ralph Malicki.
The county clerk’s office sent the memo to Racine County Eye on Tuesday after Racine County Eye sent Kramer and the corporation counsel 12 written questions about the closed session. The county did not answer the questions individually.
According to the memo:
- Schmaling commissioned the law firm in early 2024, on the advice of counsel and with the agreement of then-County Executive Jonathan Delagrave and Kramer.
- The investigation was separate from the criminal case against Kite, which the Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office handled.
- It ran about 12 months and included voluntary interviews with at least 13 witnesses.
- It produced three reports: two dated Dec. 2, 2024, and the Feb. 4, 2025, follow-up.
- It concluded there was no evidence of widespread misconduct or sexual harassment within the Sheriff’s Office. It recommended a personnel review, possible retraining of staff and supervisors on identifying and reporting sexual harassment, and an anonymous way for employees to report.
- It recommended a personnel investigation of Madrigal’s response to allegations that another deputy received “inappropriate photos” from Kite. Those findings and recommendations became the basis for her discipline.
The count of three reports is new. Racine County Eye reported in August that there were two.
The two county documents also differ on one point. Kramer’s release refers to “an inappropriate photo.” Lanzdorf’s memo refers to “inappropriate photos.” Madrigal has said she knew of one.
She was “only ever made aware of the one photo mentioned to me in November 2023,” Madrigal told Racine County Eye in August.
Kite was arrested in February 2024 and convicted of 21 felonies, 20 of them child sex crimes, in Racine County cases 2024CF000164 and 2024CF000247. He is serving 90 years, 55 of them in prison, court records show. He has filed a motion for postconviction relief, and a hearing is set for Nov. 30, according to the court record.
The county’s lawyer urged caution
Lanzdorf’s memo, written four days before the committee’s vote, argued for keeping the reports confidential.
Witnesses, “particularly subordinate staff,” volunteered information and could face privacy or retaliation risks, he wrote, and releasing the reports could discourage people from cooperating with future investigations. He called waiving attorney-client privilege “an extraordinary step that should not be taken lightly,” and wrote that releasing the reports “would have a lasting and chilling effect.”
He also wrote that accounts of the investigation’s “believed findings” had “circulated and become amplified (and took on gross mischaracterization)” during the sheriff’s race.
The board’s motion would release “redacted” versions of the reports. The release does not say what would be blacked out.
What the closed session covered
The meeting notice closed the Kite item under a state open meetings exemption for conferring with lawyers about litigation the county “is or is likely to become involved” in. Racine County Eye asked the county Monday what that litigation is and whether anyone has filed a claim or lawsuit against the county related to Kite. The memo does not say.
The committee also met in closed session on “a pending personnel matter related to a public employee of the Racine County Sheriff’s Office,” the release says. The meeting notice described that item as “the dismissal, demotion, discipline, or investigation of a public employee within the Racine County Sheriff’s Office.” Neither document names the employee, and the release does not say whether the committee took any action on that matter.
The Sheriff’s Office confirmed Nov. 7 that Schmaling had placed Madrigal on administrative leave, citing a criminal investigation of another person and an internal review of her actions. Neither the release nor the memo says whether the pending personnel matter involves her.
On Wednesday, the Sheriff’s Office tied the leave to the Union Grove case for the first time. In a media update dated Nov. 17, it said the office learned Nov. 6 of an allegation involving Madrigal related to the investigation of Thomas Johnson, the Union Grove Union High School district administrator. Schmaling placed her on leave and asked the Wisconsin Department of Justice to investigate her alleged involvement, according to the update. It does not say what the allegation is.
The update says Schmaling asked the state to take that investigation “based on the recent elections and the involvement of local officials.” He had earlier sent the Johnson investigation to Kenosha County because of “the sheriff’s office relationship with Johnson” and because the office contracts a school resource deputy at Union Grove High School, according to the update.
Racine County Eye asked the Wisconsin Department of Justice whether it received Schmaling’s request, whether its Division of Criminal Investigation has opened an investigation and whether Madrigal is a subject. The department said in an email Wednesday evening that it “generally does not confirm or deny the existence of an investigation, except in unique public safety circumstances.”
Johnson is charged in Kenosha County Circuit Court with two felony counts of possessing child pornography, the term Wisconsin law uses for child sexual abuse material. He has pleaded not guilty and is presumed innocent unless and until convicted. The update reprints the Sheriff’s Office’s Nov. 7 statement that Madrigal is not the focus or subject of the criminal investigation.
The Nov. 7 statement said Schmaling had turned “the allegations” over to the Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office. Kenosha County told Racine County Eye on Nov. 9 that it took over the Johnson investigation and is not conducting an internal investigation of Madrigal. The new update says the Sheriff’s Office will do a separate internal review once the state investigation is finished.
Racine County Eye sent the Sheriff’s Office eight questions Monday, including whether Madrigal is the employee referenced in the meeting notice and whether she is still on leave. The Sheriff’s Office had not responded as of Wednesday evening.
On Wednesday afternoon, Racine County Eye also sent Madrigal and the Sheriff’s Office questions about the media update, including what the allegation is and whether Madrigal is still not a subject of the criminal investigation. Neither had responded by the 6 p.m. Wednesday deadline. Racine County Eye separately asked both for comment on the planned release of the reports and will update this story when they respond.
Who decides
The sheriff, an independently elected official, runs personnel matters inside the Sheriff’s Office. Lanzdorf’s memo says misconduct investigations there usually stay with the office’s professional standards unit, human resources or county lawyers, without the County Board, unless an employee facing discipline asks for a hearing before the Grievance Committee.
Whether to waive the privilege on these reports is now before the full County Board, which takes up the resolution Dec. 8.
Donald Vandervest, who won the Nov. 3 election for sheriff, takes office in January.
What we don’t know
- How supervisors voted Tuesday night.
- Which of the three reports would stay private. The motion covers two: one dated Dec. 2, 2024, and the Feb. 4, 2025, follow-up.
- What would be redacted.
- What litigation the county is involved in or expects.
- Whether the Sheriff’s Office carried out the recommended retraining and anonymous reporting system.
- Who the pending personnel matter involves, and whether the committee acted on it.
- What the allegation involving Madrigal is, and whether the state Division of Criminal Investigation has opened an investigation.
What we’ll check next
Racine County Eye will report on the resolution when Corporation Counsel drafts it and when the County Board votes Dec. 8. If the board approves it, we will read the reports and report what they say. We have also asked for the investigation’s engagement letter, any authorizing directive and invoices paid to date under Wisconsin’s public records law.
Related coverage
- Sheriff places Capt. Cary Madrigal on administrative leave, citing a criminal investigation of someone else and a review of her actions (Nov. 7, 2026)
- Voters are hearing a lot about Cary Madrigal. Here’s what the records show. (Aug. 8, 2026)
Disclosure: The Madrigal campaign purchased advertising on Racine County Eye during the 2026 election. Advertising has no role in our editorial decisions.
Sources: Racine County Board Chairman Tom Kramer media release, Nov. 18, 2026; Racine County Corporation Counsel memo, Nov. 13, 2026; Committee of the Whole meeting notice for Nov. 17, 2026; Racine County Circuit Court cases 2026CV000280, 2024CF000164 and 2024CF000247; Racine County Eye reporting.
Additional sources for the Nov. 18 updates: Racine County Sheriff’s Office media update dated Nov. 17, 2026; Racine County Sheriff’s Office statement, Nov. 7, 2026; Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office email to Racine County Eye, Nov. 9, 2026; Kenosha County Circuit Court case 2026CF001581; Wisconsin Department of Justice email to Racine County Eye, Nov. 18, 2026.
Reported by Denise Lockwood. Racine County Eye used AI tools to help draft and organize this story from documents; a journalist verified every fact.

