Milwaukee Black Media Logo
Little Trickles Become Big Drops: Why Milwaukee Public Schools’ Fiscal Oversight Should Return to the School Board

•

5 min read

Little Trickles Become Big Drops: Why Milwaukee Public Schools’ Fiscal Oversight Should Return to the School Board

Nov 20, 2026, 12:00 PM CT

Share


In recent weeks, Milwaukee Public Schools administrators asked the Board of School Directors to approve about $3.6 million in spending that had already happened. The money covered dental equipment, asbestos cleanup, architectural design plans and furniture at six schools, all tied to the district’s $18 million long-range facilities plan. When Board Vice President James Ferguson asked whether the work was done, Facilities Director Mike Turza stated, “Projects have already been completed, and the money is owed to the companies.”

Board Director Christopher Fons put the problem in one sentence: “We should never be voting on things after the fact.”

In a district with a budget of roughly $1.6 billion, $3.6 million is a small share. That is exactly the point. Little trickles become big drops when nobody elected to watch the faucet is told it is running. Milwaukee has seen what happens when that goes on for years, and it is time to ask why the board that voters elect to oversee MPS has so little say over its money.

How 1991 Wisconsin Act 39 moved the money

Before 1991, state law required MPS to have a secretary-business manager, a position that kept the district’s financial records and held significant power over the budget. The superintendent ran instruction. The business manager ran the money. Other Wisconsin districts, by contrast, assign financial roles such as clerk and treasurer to board members.

1991 Wisconsin Act 39 removed that position and moved financial oversight to the superintendent. Then-Superintendent Howard Fuller, who pushed for the change, asked how he could be responsible for education and have no power over personnel and finances. In spring 1992, the board adopted a plan to eliminate the post and hand its duties to the superintendent.

The result is an arrangement found nowhere else in Wisconsin. MPS is the only school district in the state where financial control sits with the superintendent rather than with the elected board. The district’s own board has since tried to claw back some visibility: in 2010 it created the Office of Accountability and Efficiency, which reports to the board. But an office that reports to the board is not the same as a board that holds the authority.

Supporters of the 1991 change said a superintendent held to account for results needed control over people and money. That is a fair argument. It also assumes that the person with the control will tell the public, and the board, what is being spent. Sadly, this has not been the case in MPS for some time.

A string of fiscal crises

The latest $3.6 million request did not arrive in a calm stretch. It followed more than two years of financial trouble.

2024: egregiously late reports and a leadership exit. MPS fell behind on the financial reports and audits the state needs to calculate aid. The state Department of Public Instruction withheld a special education payment of $16.6 million, and the problems led to the resignation of Superintendent Keith Posley. The chief financial officer Martha Kreitzman retired, and the comptroller Alfredo Balmaseda was fired the next day.

2025: a state audit and a repeat failure. An operations audit ordered by Gov. Tony Evers, conducted by MGT of America Consulting at a cost of $2.5 million, found that the central office was not positioned to support schools and that the administration and the school board lacked clear roles. It made 29 recommendations. The same year, MPS missed state reporting deadlines for a second consecutive year, and the state suspended funding again. An $8 million achievement gap payment was withheld until January 2026.

2026: a $46 million overrun. In February, audits showed MPS had overspent its budget by $46 million in the prior school year, about 2.9 percent of a $1.54 billion budget. Transportation and food costs were the main drivers. Superintendent Brenda Cassellius said the overspending went on for, “many, many, year.” The district froze non-essential hiring, and the board later approved a plan to 260 positions.

November 2026: a bank impersonation scam. MPS announced it had lost $450,000 to bank impersonation fraud, recovered $255,000 and was working to recover the remaining $195,000. Meanwhile, MPS CFO Aycha Sawa was still employed by the district as of November 5th and a criminal investigation is under way.

The $3.6 million the board did not know about

District policy, as reported, requires that change orders over $25,000 be reported to the board as soon as practicable or within 60 days after completion. Changes over $50,000 need approval from an executive officer, with notice to the board within 60 days. Therefore, the rule asks the board to learn about spending after it happens.

Superintendent Cassellius said the district’s chief operating officer approved the $3.6 million. Left unanswered were when that approval came, whether it preceded the work, and whether the board was told on time. Cassellius said she knew the general categories but wanted specifics before discussing them publicly.

Board President Missy Zombor said she believes the spending did not follow policy and that, even if policy allows after-the-fact action, the board should not take it while trying to restore trust in district finances. Director Fons asked what would happen if the board voted no. The answer: the district would have to find the money to pay the contracts anyway. That is not oversight; that is a signal that the board needs to tighten its administrative policy as soon as possible and advocate for a legislative repeal of 1991 Act 39.

Return the oversight to the people who answer to voters

The School Board is elected by Milwaukee residents. The superintendent is hired and can be dismissed by that board. When the board holds no real authority over the money, the public’s representatives are left to read about decisions in the news and vote on them afterward. This is ludicrous.

Returning fiscal oversight to the board does not mean the board should run the district day to day. It means restoring the checks that every other Wisconsin district takes for granted. Those checks could include:

  • A finance officer who reports to the board, not only to the superintendent.
  • Board approval before spending above a set threshold, replacing reports sent up to 60 days after the work is finished.
  • Regular, plain-language budget-to-actual reports to the board and the public, so overspending is caught in months, not years.
  • A clear definition of the board’s and the administration’s roles, as the state-ordered audit urged.

MPS has made progress on its audits and its reporting, and the people doing that work deserve credit. But the fixes of the last two years were driven by state pressure, a governor’s audit and a scandal. Lasting accountability should not depend on a crisis. Strong oversight needs a structure that works when things are going well, and that is what 1991 Wisconsin Act 39 removed.

Milwaukee’s children, families and taxpayers deserve a board that sees the spending before it is done. The faucet should never run unwatched.

LaKeshia N. Myers

Dr. LaKeshia Nicole Myers is an accomplished education leader, public servant, and advocate for educational excellence with more than 17 years of experience across K–12, higher education, and public policy. A former member of the Wisconsin State Assembly (2019–2024), she championed education initiatives while serving on key legislative committees and previously worked in federal policy with the U.S. House of Representatives. Dr. Myers currently serves as an Adjunct Professor of History at Lakeland University and Managing Partner of EduStar Consulting, bringing deep expertise in instructional leadership, special education, and equity-focused educational reform.

WNOV black BG 500×500

2003 W Capitol Dr, Milwaukee WI 53206

Studio: (414) 441-6991 (text or call)

Office: (414) 449-5490

info@wnov860.com


860 WNOV
860 WNOV